Engagement Ring Shopping Guide From The Treasury on the Plaza

Engagement Ring Shopping Guide From The Treasury on the Plaza

The Treasury on the Plaza’s guide to engagement ring shopping


Shoppers today seem to have access to anything and everything at the touch of a button. You can purchase clothes, your groceries, or even a car, and have them delivered right to your door! With this much accessibility, you would think that engagement ring shopping is easier than ever before. Although the process of purchasing might be easier, finding the right ring can still be a challenge. Knowing this, The Treasury on the Plaza has created a handy guide to engagement ring shopping. First, we’ll be sharing how to buy an engagement ring, then we’ll discuss the best time to buy an engagement ring based on when you want to propose. Finally, we’ll share some advice from real couples on shopping for the perfect engagement ring!



1. How To Buy An Engagement Ring


For most people, purchasing an engagement ring only happens once in a lifetime, so knowing where to start can be very overwhelming. It’s a large investment, a massive milestone moment, and one of the biggest questions you will ask someone in your entire life! So how do you buy an engagement ring? 


Start by looking online for engagement ring ideas


Like other large purchases, starting online gives you endless information to help you get started with buying an engagement ring—from ring pricing, to ring design ideas, and where to buy an engagement ring. Social media sites like Pinterest are a good starting point for your engagement ring research. Searching for “engagement ring shopping” will give you endless links to other sites with resources.

If you are looking to surprise your partner with a ring, consider looking online in ‘incognito mode’ so your searches don’t pop up in your browser history. You don’t want to give away the surprise too early!


Where to buy an engagement ring


When you begin shopping, you may be overwhelmed by the amount of information or styles available for engagement rings. Orlando, Florida-based engagement ring designer Sandy Rubin says, “it is okay if you don’t know exactly what you want. It can take a conversation with a jeweler, and looking at several options, to help you gain a better understanding. Work with a designer that makes you feel comfortable and will help walk you through the process.” 

Engagement Ring Ideas From Sandy Rubin in Orlando FloridaEngagement Ring Ideas From Sandy Rubin in Orlando Florida



Consider shopping at a local jeweler, rather than through large jewelry shops. Local shops are known to be more personal and responsive, provide more ring education, and have better inventory options. “Walk into a local jewelry store and you should have access to the deep knowledge base of your experienced gemologist and jewelry. You should be free to ask any and every question,” says Clay Nettles, owner of Nettles Fine Jewelry in St. Augustine, Florida.  



Local jewelry shops will allow you to shop and explore ring options that may only be available to your local area. Larger stores supply rings that interest the general population, so when you purchase from a chain jeweler, there is a high chance that someone you know may have the same ring as your fiance. Brides today are requesting non-traditional engagement rings, often with stones like emerald or sapphire, which may not be as available in engagement rings in larger shops. 


Ask friends or family for help with engagement ring shopping


Before purchasing an engagement ring, ask your partner’s best friend or family member for help. No one will know their style better! Oftentimes friends send a ‘just in case’ image as inspiration for their dream engagement ring. Your partner’s friends may already have an image or an idea of what they love. Going shopping with a sibling or future in-law may also help you score some additional brownie points!

Treasury on the Plaza bride Lindsey worked with her family to make sure that her now-husband Rory had an idea of what she liked before he went shopping. “I went to Diamonds Direct and picked out what I liked with my cousin. They wrote down my ‘likes’ on a card for Rory to have when he went shopping. It was a great experience!” Lindsey adds, “With it being such a big purchase for something that will be worn your whole life, it is very acceptable for the girl to have some impact!”

Get it, girl! We love that Lindsay was proactive in making sure that she got a ring that she loved!  As you can tell from the photo below, she has great taste!




2. The Best Time To Buy an Engagement Ring 


The most popular time to get engaged (known as “engagement season” in the industry) is between Thanksgiving and Valentine’s Day. The general cheer of the season, family visits, travel opportunities, and multiple holidays all make for the perfect time to pop the question!

With this in mind, someone planning to propose during this window of time should plan ahead! Custom rings can take up to three months to be designed and delivered. If you are completely unsure of what style ring your partner would like, begin researching styles and shops in the summer months, so you have a few months before purchasing and don’t feel rushed. Laurel with Anchor Boutique in St. Augustine, Florida recommends going ring shopping about 8 weeks before you plan to purpose.

Where to shop for an engagement ring in St. Augustine

Photo of Laurel Baker, owner of Anchor Boutique, by Evergold Photography

If you are planning to propose during the engagement season, this means that you should consider purchasing a ring in August or September. Be sure to call around and contact jewelers to learn more about their specific ordering information. Your jeweler will share their honest advice and give you more specifics into the timeline and delivery dates. 



3. Engagement Ring Advice From Real Couples 


Katherine & Will

“We went to a few jewelers in Atlanta to see what cut I liked. Then my husband spoke with Liz Legg, a local jeweler in Birmingham, AL, who makes beautiful heirloom like jewelry and she created my ring.” Katherine’s advice for engagement ring shopping is to “plan ahead of time and make sure you’re going to get it in time for when you want to propose. Also, going through a local jeweler is cheaper than those [large] diamond stores. Liz Legg handpicked a few diamonds from her diamond buyer in NYC for us and it was much cheaper than buying a ring already made.”

Engagement Ring Advice From Real Couples

Photo of Katherine and Will’s Treasury on the Plaza wedding by Colin Goodman 


Sara & Michael

“Michael custom made the ring on We had gone multiple times to look at rings and I thought for a FACT I wanted a double halo cushion cut… until the last time we tried them on and I fell in LOVE with my shape. He took that as inspiration and created the masterpiece all by himself. I had no idea what the ring would look like but I trusted Michael enough to pick the one he thought would be perfect based on my guidance.”

Engagement Ring Advice From Real Couples


Adrianne & Jake 

Jake purchased Adrianne’s engagement ring from International Diamond Center. “He was able to look at multiple diamonds in varying sizes, cuts, and colors. He basically designed the ring himself and he was very proud of that!” Adrianne’s advice: “If you have a particular cut or style in mind (and you’ve already talked about getting engaged), make it known!”

Engagement Ring Shopping Advice From Real Couples


We hope that you have enjoyed The Treasury on the Plaza‘s Guide to Engagement Ring Shopping!

Purchasing an engagement ring is a big investment. It is one of the most important gifts you will ever give to someone. While there are pressures to purchasing the right ring, there are also resources. Be sure to look online, ask your partner’s friends and family, and to call around or walk into local shops to start shopping for the perfect engagement ring. No matter which ring you choose, your partner will love all of the thought and effort that you put into picking something special!


Once they say ‘yes!’ be sure to check out The Treasury on the Plaza’s ultimate wedding planning guide and contact our team for more information about planning your upcoming wedding. 


Contact Us Call to Action



Treasury On The Plaza Map Location

Visit us

24 Cathedral Place
Suite 111
St. Augustine, FL 32084

Write us

Email :

Call us

Office : (904) 217-0077


We can't wait to hear more about your celebration!

Step 1 of 4 - Basic Info


Please provide a few details before downloading our packages.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Treasury on the Plaza Logo


The Treasury is open and available for in-person tours, weddings, and events!

Our commitment to the health and well-being of all those who walk through our doors continues to be top of mind 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

All staff and vendors are required to wear masks during events, and during any other customer interactions, which include meetings and tours.

Before our venue opens each day we disinfect the venue with a fogger machine.  The fog is used to reduce the number of airborne microorganisms while it applies disinfectant to all surfaces immediately.

We are proud to announce that we have invested in and installed the Air Scrubber by Aerus into our Air Conditioning’s Ventilation Systems.  This system combines high-intensity UVC lighting with a state-of-the-art process that destroys over 99% of airborne and surface contaminants. This is the same technology that was built for NASA and is used on the International Space Station.

The Treasury is following customized guidelines created by Automated Clinical Guidelines to sanitize high-traffic areas every 45 minutes during events.

Sanitizing stations have been installed throughout the building.

Watch the video below to learn more about the steps that we are taking to ensure the health and safety of all of our couples and guests!


Our promise to you is that we continue to evaluate, invest, and implement the newest technologies to ensure the safety of everyone who comes to celebrate with us.

If you have questions, please contact our team at