Our Top 10 St. Augustine Proposal Ideas

Our Top 10 St. Augustine Proposal Ideas

You’ve found the perfect partner that you want to spend the rest of your life with. Way to go! Finding the love of your life is no small feat, but after you’ve made this important decision comes a somewhat daunting task–coming up with ideas for the perfect proposal. The day that you propose is one of the most important and memorable days of your life, not to mention, with the advent of social media your engagement story will probably be shared hundreds of times with all of your closest friends and family. But no pressure.

Step one in crafting the perfect marriage proposal is determining the ideal location for you to get down on one knee. With its beautiful historic buildings, charming streets, shops, restaurants, and beautiful beaches, St. Augustine is the perfect destination for popping the question. We’re helping you get one step closer to a guaranteed “Yes!” by sharing our top 10 St. Augustine proposal ideas!

St. Augustine Lighthouse | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by Jenna Alexander Photography

1. The Top of the St. Augustine Lighthouse


Do you want your love to feel like they are on the top of the world when you propose? Take them up to the top of the St. Augustine Lighthouse. You’ll see majestic views of the surrounding beaches, Matanzas Bay, and historic downtown St. Augustine. It’s the perfect spot to take your commitment to new heights…just be careful not to drop the ring!

Click here for more information on St. Augustine Lighthouse Tours.


Lightner Museum courtyard proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo via How He Asked

2. The Lightner Museum Courtyard


For those looking for a tranquil, private location to get down on one knee, the central courtyard of the Lightner Museum is the perfect spot. The Courtyard features a charming stone bridge over a rippling Koi pond, surrounded by lush landscaping and swaying palm trees. During the wintertime, the courtyard is even lit up with twinkling lights as a part of the Nights of Lights celebration.

Click here to visit the Lightner Museum website.


Nights of Lights Proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by Maris Kirs Photography

3. The Plaza de la Constitución during Nights of Lights


St. Augustine is truly magical during the months of November through January when the city lights up for the annual Nights of Lights celebration. For those looking to share their love and commitment in front of a large crowd, consider proposing during the lighting ceremony in the Plaza de la Constitución, which typically takes place on Saturday before Thanksgiving. Just make sure to get there early to pick out the perfect spot!

Click here for more information on Nights of Lights in St. Augustine.


St. Augustine beach proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by Josh Haltam Photography

4. St. Augustine Beach Proposal at Sunset


If you’re looking for a St. Augustine proposal idea that will provide picturesque photo opportunities, look no further than St. Augustine Beach. TripAdvisor recently rated St. Augustine Beach as one of its Top 25 Beaches in the U.S., and it’s easy to see why. The sparkling white sands extend for miles, and you can even drive out on the beach in certain locations. We recommend packing a picnic to enjoy the beautiful colors of the sunset over the water.


Horse-drawn carriage proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by David Walters Photography

5. A Romantic Carriage Ride Around Historic Downtown


It’s hard to think of a more classically romantic St. Augustine proposal idea than a horse-drawn carriage ride. You’ll be able to sit back, relax, and learn about the history of the nation’s oldest city. Then, when the time is right, the driver can take you to the perfect proposal location. Afterward, you can stroll hand-in-hand through the streets, or stop off at one of St. Augustine’s award winning restaurants.


Sailboat at sunset proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo via Schooner Freedom Charters

6. Sailboat Ride on the Matanzas Bay


The Schooner Freedom offers a Romantic Sunset Sail with beautiful views out over the Matanzas Bay. You can sip on cold beverages and cuddle with your sweetheart as you watch the sun go down over the St. Augustine skyline. After your proposal, you can literally sail off into the sunset together!


Castillo de San Marcos proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by Monarch Studios

7.  The Castillo de San Marcos


St. Augustine is known for its rich culture and history, and there are few places more unique and historic than the fort! The Castillo de San Marcos has stood on the banks of the Matanzas River since the 1600’s, and is one of the most recognized landmarks in St. Augustine. Its location on the Bayfront is also ideal for pictures with the famous Bridge of Lions in the background.


Castillo de San Marcos proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by Footstone Photography

8. Davenport Park Carousel


For a unique location off the beaten path, consider the Davenport Park Carousel. Located North of downtown, this vintage carousel has the makings of a perfect location for a surprise proposal.


Love Tree Proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza

Photo by Victoria Angela Photography

9. Under One of St. Augustine’s “Love Trees”


What is a “love tree” you ask? A love tree is where two separate species of trees grow in, on, or through one another. Local legend states that when two lovers kiss beneath one of these rare trees, that their love will be sealed for eternity. There are several love trees throughout St. Augustine, including one on the corner of Cordova Street and Orange Street.


Treasury on the Plaza Proposal | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza


10. Your Fiance’s Dream Wedding Venue


Let’s face it; some couples have their entire wedding day planned well before they get engaged. If you are thinking about hosting your wedding at one of St. Augustine’s beautiful wedding venues, consider popping the question in the same location where you want to say “I do!” We recently had our first proposal at The Treasury on the Plaza. Daniel surprised his fiance Tayla by getting down on one knee during a venue tour. We can’t wait for their upcoming wedding!


Are you recently engaged? We’d love to hear your engagement story! Direct message us on Facebook or Instagram, use the hashtag #staugustineproposal, or tag us in your post using @treasuryontheplaza. We’ll be sharing our favorite proposals with all of our followers!

Share your engagement! | St. Augustine proposal ideas | Treasury on the Plaza


Visit us

24 Cathedral Place
Suite 111
St. Augustine, FL 32084

Write us

Email : [email protected]

Call us

Office : (904) 217-0077

Contact Us / Book A Tour

  • Select all that apply.

We can't wait to hear more about your event!

Step 1 of 4 - Basic Info



Please provide a few details before downloading our packages.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.